• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
McKenna Storer

McKenna Storer

AV Rated Chicago Law Firm

  • Home
  • Insurance
    • Insurance Defense
    • Toxic Tort and Mass Tort Litigation
    • Construction Law
    • Commercial Transportation Law
    • Insurance Coverage
    • Professional Malpractice Defense
    • Medical Malpractice Defense
    • Legal Malpractice Defense
    • Appellate Practice
  • Business
    • Corporate Law & Commercial Litigation
    • Litigation Defense
    • SBA Lending
    • Commercial Real Estate
    • Appellate Practice
    • Health Care Law
    • Business Formation
    • Data Privacy and Cyber Liability
    • Employment Law
    • Employment Litigation
    • Workplace Harassment
  • Individual
    • Estate Planning
    • Wills and Trusts
    • Real Estate
    • Mediation Services
  • Banking Law
  • Our Attorneys
  • Our Firm
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
    • Chicago Office
    • Woodstock Office
  • Show Search
Hide Search

Unexpected Finding at Autopsy of a Perforated Duodenal Ulcer Results in Winning Verdict for a Cardiologist and Five Other Defendants Retrospectively Charged with Medical Negligence

Julie Ramson · June 7, 2019 ·

In March and April Julie Ramson and Dawn Ehrenberg won a case involving a young woman, age 22, who passed away from sepsis following a ruptured duodenal ulcer. The ulcer was not discovered until autopsy because the young woman was admitted with generalized weakness, neurological abnormalities, an abnormal EKG and hypertension. She did not complain of any GI or abdominal symptoms during the admission. She was seen by our client, the cardiologist, as well as specialists in ENT, Neurology, Infectious Disease and Internal Medicine. All were defendants along with the hospital.

The patient deteriorated after admission despite the best efforts of the primary care physician as well as our cardiologist and five other defendants. Her diagnosis was complicated by the fact that she weighed over 360 lb and, despite the doctors’ order for a CT, she could not have this test because the CT machines could not accommodate her size. She deteriorated during the hospitalization and died seven days after admission.

On autopsy, the pathologist found she had a previously undiagnosed duodenal ulcer, which perforated during this admission and resulted in an abdominal infection that spread to her blood stream. Because she showed no symptoms of an abdominal problem, the diagnosis of a perforated ulcer was not made until autopsy. This case was defended solely on the post-mortem findings.

The plaintiff’s attorney alleged that each of the defendant physicians breached his duty by failing to recognize the symptoms of a perforated duodenal ulcer and failing to order a timely gastrointestinal consult. He argued that if called in to see the patient, a GI specialist would have discovered the ulcer before it perforated and would have treated it, thereby saving the young woman’s life. Since the patient had no abdominal symptoms until a few hours before her death, the plaintiff’s allegations that the defendant physicians were negligent in failing to diagnose the ulcer were significantly weakened.

All six defendants were found not guilty of medical malpractice. After rendering the verdict, the jurors stated that they believed the defense experts who testified that such duodenal ulcers can occur without symptoms and then go on to rupture without there being any medical negligence.

Please contact Julie Ramson and Dawn Ehrenberg for questions about this case or similar medical negligence defense matters. Julie Ramson is a partner with McKenna Storer. Julie is a trial attorney and focuses her practice on defending medical professionals and medical products. She has been with McKenna Storer for more than 37 years with an impressive record of success.

Dawn Ehenberg is a partner with McKenna Storer. She has concentrated her practice on defending medical professionals, including physicians, nurses and other health care professionals in medical negligence defense suits with very successful results.

General Litigation, Medical Malpractice Defense

About Julie Ramson

Julie Ramson has practiced medical malpractice defense for over thirty years. Prior to that, she worked as a Registered Nurse for several years as a staff nurse, a Head Nurse for an Emergency Department, and a Medical ICU and then as a Director of Nursing for a small surgical hospital. Her background as a nurse in the medical field has provided a good understanding of the everyday practice of doctors, nurses and other health care workers in a variety of fields. It has also allowed her to develop a signature approach to medical trials and how to best explain the medical issues of a case in lay terms to a jury. Because of her ability to explain these issues clearly, she has an impressive trial success record. Read her full bio here: Julie A. Ramson Full Bio

Chicago Office
McKenna, Storer
33 N. LaSalle, Suite 1400
Chicago, Illinois 60602
312.558.3900
312.558.8348
Mo,Tu,We,Th,Fr 8:30 am – 5:00 pm
Woodstock Office
McKenna, Storer
1060 Lake Avenue
Woodstock, Illinois 60098
815.334.9690
815.334.9697
Mo,Tu,We,Th 8:30 am – 5:00 pm

  • Home
  • Insurance
  • Business
  • Individual
  • Banking Law
  • Our Attorneys
  • Our Firm
  • Blog
  • Contact Us